Intrinsic Value and the Genetic Engineering of Animals.
until further notice
SourceEnvironmental Values, 17, 3, (2008), pp. 375-392
Article / Letter to editor
Display more detailsDisplay less details
Ethics, Philosophy, History of Medical Sciences
Leerstoel Praktische filosofie
SubjectEBP 4: Quality of Care; NCEBP 2: Evaluation of complex medical interventions; NCEBP 5: Health care ethics
The concept of intrinsic value is often invoked to articulate objections to the genetic engineering of animals, particularly those objections that are not directed at the negative effects the technique might have on the health and welfare of the modified animals. However, this concept was not developed in the context of genetic engineering. Given this external origin, this paper critically examines the assumption that the concept of intrinsic value is suitable to articulate and justify moral objections more specifically directed at the genetic engineering of animals. I discuss four different theories of intrinsic value, two of which defend a moral concept of intrinsic value and two a non-moral one. I conclude that only a particular non-moral concept of intrinsic value is suitable to express specific objections to genetic engineering, because these objections can only be defended in the form of indirect duties regarding animals.
This item appears in the following Collection(s)
- Academic publications 
- Electronic publications 
- Faculty of Medical Sciences 
- Faculty of Philosophy, Theology and Religious Studies 
Upload full text