
Fulltext:
224663.pdf
Embargo:
until further notice
Size:
449.9Kb
Format:
PDF
Description:
Publisher’s version
Publication year
2014Author(s)
Source
Ecological Economics, 105, (2014), pp. 40-47ISSN
Publication type
Article / Letter to editor

Display more detailsDisplay less details
Organization
Leerstoel Wijsgerige ethiek en politieke filosofie
Journal title
Ecological Economics
Volume
vol. 105
Page start
p. 40
Page end
p. 47
Subject
Center for Political Philosophy and Ethics (CPPE)Abstract
In cost-benefit analysis of climate policy there are two main approaches to discounting, each with implications conflicting with our moral intuitions. Thus, discounted utilitarianism implies that we hardly need to protect future generations against climate change, while classical utilitarianism implies that we should reduce our consumption across the board to benefit future generations. The insolubility of the debate derives from the fact that both classical and discounted utilitarianism permit only a single discount rate for all consequences occurring in the same future year, while our intuitions clearly do distinguish between consequences, depending on whether we cause adverse effects on other people's interests and violate their rights. Most people share the moral intuition that we ought to refrain from harming others, and ought to compensate them if we were unable to prevent harm. To regain a reflective equilibrium between such deontological intuitions and economic theory there is a need to accept different discount rates for different situations: a zero consumption discount rate in the case of cost-benefit analysis of measures to prevent wrongful harm to future generations, and standard discounting in all other cases. Applying a zero consumption discount rate means that future generations are automatically largely compensated for climate damage that remains unmitigated.
This item appears in the following Collection(s)
- Non RU Publications [14895]
Upload full text
Use your RU credentials (u/z-number and password) to log in with SURFconext to upload a file for processing by the repository team.