The Size of History. Coincidence, Counterfactuality and Questions
Dordrecht : Springer Verlag
The Frontiers Collection
InLandsman, Klaas; Wolde, Ellen van (ed.), The Challenge of Chance. A Multidisciplinary Approach from Science and the Humanities, pp. 215-232
Part of book or chapter of book
Display more detailsDisplay less details
Wolde, Ellen van
Landsman, Klaas; Wolde, Ellen van (ed.), The Challenge of Chance. A Multidisciplinary Approach from Science and the Humanities
SubjectEurope and its Worlds before 1800; The Ancient World
Historians try to interpret the past by analysing patterns in human behaviour in earlier periods of time. In some ways, that excludes ‘coincidence’ as a mode of interpretation. Most historians view coincidences as closely related events that lack causal relationship. That type of coincidence does not fit into a historical narrative, because historians tend to focus on causality, action, and consequence. This is noticeably linked to questions of historical scale: the choice for the scale of a specific narrative decides whether certain events are coincidental to the history which is being described, or causal factors within that history. This relation between historical coincidence and the scale of writing history is at the centre of this contribution. It focuses on different trends in writing history, and analyses the possibilities to use ‘coincidence’ as an interpretative tool in each of them. In doing so, this article discusses counterfactual historical analysis (‘what if history’), determinist views of history and their relation to speculative philosophy of history, ‘cliodynamics’ and ‘big history’. It ultimately argues for historical accounts that pay attention to both the large processes that are likely to lead to certain trajectories, and the enormous number of micro-causes that triggered the events as they happened. Coincidence might fall outside of the analysis of (macro-) historians who are looking for a comprehensive view of historical processes, but could still play a proper role in thinking about historical trajectories.
Upload full text
Use your RU credentials (u/z-number and password) to log in with SURFconext to upload a file for processing by the repository team.