Mechanical properties of porous, electrosprayed calcium phosphate coatings

Abstract

Mechanical properties of calcium phosphate coatings (CaP), deposited using the electrostatic spray deposition (ESD) technique, have been characterized using a range of analytical techniques, including tensile testing (ASTM C633), fatigue testing (ASTM E855), and scratch testing using blunt and sharp scratch styli. Moreover, a simple explantation procedure was successfully introduced using ESD-coated, threaded dental implants to characterize the mechanical performance of CaP coatings qualitatively under conditions that mimic clinical situations as close as possible. Generally, all analysis techniques revealed that ESD coatings need to be crystallized in order to ensure interfacial adhesion to the substrate and sufficient mechanical strength of the superficial reticular structure. Crystalline carbonated hydroxyapatite coatings (CHA, heat-treated at 700 degrees C) were resistant to fatigue as well as to plastic ploughing deformation by means of various scratch styli, and the fragile surface structure of ESD coatings was maintained to a large extent after unscrewing CHA-coated dental implants from femoral condyles of goat cadavers. From these experiments, it was concluded that interfacial adhesion of crystalline CHA ESD coatings to the titanium substrate was sufficient, but that mechanical strength of the superficial architecture of ESD coatings need to be optimized for applications where high shear and compressive stresses are imposed onto the rather fragile coating surface of reticular ESD morphologies.